Alright, let’s talk about MLB The Show 24. Fired it up pretty much day one, you know, eager to get swinging. But right away, I noticed all these little pictures, these icons, plastered everywhere. On player cards, popping up during games, sitting there in the menus. Honestly? I had no clue what most of them meant at first.

It felt a bit like trying to read a foreign language. You see a little flame symbol, maybe that means the guy’s hot? See a shield, okay, probably defense. But then there were others… stars next to a glove? Weird symbols in Diamond Dynasty? I was mostly guessing, just trying to play through it. Sometimes my guesses were okay, sometimes, probably way off.
Digging In-Game First
So, my first thought was, okay, the answer’s gotta be in the game somewhere, right? Developers usually put in a guide or something. I spent a good chunk of time just clicking around the main menus. Looked for a ‘Help’ section, a ‘Glossary’, maybe a tutorial replay. Found some basic stuff, sure, how to hit, how to pitch, the usual. But a nice, clean list explaining every single little icon? Couldn’t find one easily.
Then I started really staring at the player cards. Sometimes, if you hover over stats or specific areas, a little box pops up with info. That helped for a few things, like maybe clarifying what a specific attribute number meant. But the icons themselves? Not always. Especially the ‘Quirk’ icons. Lots of little pictures, but hovering didn’t spell it out clearly all the time.
I figured maybe playing different modes would shed some light. Like, maybe Road to the Show would explain its specific progression icons better, or Diamond Dynasty would have clearer tooltips for its unique symbols. Played a bit of Conquest, messed with Mini Seasons. It helped a little, you pick things up piece by piece in context, but it still felt incomplete.
Looking at What Others Found
After hitting a bit of a wall just using the game itself, I did what most folks probably do – I went to see what other players were saying. Not looking for cheats or anything, just understanding the basics. Went to places online where people discuss the game, you know, forums, message boards, that kind of thing. Lo and behold, tons of other people were asking the same questions. “What does this icon mean?” “Anyone figure out the fielding symbols?”

It was actually kinda helpful seeing those discussions. One person would explain the ‘Clutch’ icon (you know, the one that looks kinda like a target or something). Someone else would break down the different fielding proficiency symbols – bronze, silver, gold, diamond shields. Another thread might be talking about the pitcher energy icons. I started mentally collecting these bits of information. It wasn’t one single source, more like crowdsourcing the answers from fellow players who had figured parts out.
Putting the Puzzle Together
So, I started piecing it all together. Like, okay:
- Quirks: These are those little descriptive icons. Stuff like ‘Day Player’, ‘First-Pitch Hitter’, ‘Cannon’ for arm strength. Each one gives a small situational boost or reflects a player’s style. Had to learn these mostly by seeing them mentioned online and then noticing them on my players.
- Fielding/Throwing Icons: Saw the different colored shields (bronze, silver, etc.) represent fielding skill level in that position. Then there’s usually an arm strength indicator too.
- Hitting/Pitching Icons: Things like the ‘Clutch’ rating icon become super important. And understanding the pitcher confidence and energy displays. There are also icons for active quirks that pop up during gameplay.
- Diamond Dynasty Specifics: This mode has its own layer, like the Parallel levels (P1, P2, etc.) showing up on cards, or icons for specific card series.
It wasn’t like I found a magic decoder ring. It was more like slowly learning the vocabulary by seeing it used and finding explanations here and there. I didn’t even write most of it down, just started recognizing them after a while.
Finally Making Sense
After actively looking and piecing together info from the game and other players, things finally started to click. It took a bit, maybe a few days of playing and reading discussions on the side. Now when I look at a player card, I actually understand what those little symbols are telling me about the player’s strengths and weaknesses in certain situations. It makes building a Diamond Dynasty team or making substitutions in Franchise mode way easier, because you actually know what you’re looking at.
So yeah, that was my little journey figuring out the icons in The Show 24. Wasn’t super straightforward, kinda had to do some digging. Just wanted to share how I went about it, in case anyone else was feeling a bit lost with all the little pictures!